Current:Home > ScamsMacKenzie Scott is shaking up philanthropy's traditions. Is that a good thing?-DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews & Ratings
MacKenzie Scott is shaking up philanthropy's traditions. Is that a good thing?
lotradecoin wallet setup guide View Date:2024-12-25 16:03:09
With the Russian invasion of Ukraine, a series of devastating climate change-fueled events and high food and energy costs, 2022 was a year of significant turmoil. But at least in the philanthropy sector, there may be reason for optimism.
On December 14, 2022 billionaire philanthropist and novelist MacKenzie Scott announced that her donations since 2019 have totaled more than $14 billion and helped fund around 1,600 nonprofits. But as much as the scale, it is the style of giving that is causing a stir; it's targeted at a wide spectrum of causes, without a formal application process and — it appears — no strings attatched.
"I cried!" admits Katherine Williford, chief growth officer of the international nonprofit Water For People, recalling the day in August 2022 that their $15 million grant was confirmed.
Williford said the previous January, a representative of someone only referred to as a "high net-worth individual" interested in promoting health and equality contacted them.
"We walked them through our plans, visions, finances. Then after six months we get $15 million with no restrictions or reporting requirements. We even offered to send an annual report or an update on the funding but they said, 'We trust you.' I've never had that happen in all my years in fundraising."
It was only when the grant was confirmed that Scott was revealed as the donor.
As of December 2022, Scott was the fifth richest woman in the U.S. with an estimated fortune of about $26 billion. Scott divorced Amazon founder and executive chairman Jeff Bezos in 2019, and as part of the settlement, received a 4% stake in Amazon. That same year, she vowed to give away her "disproportionate amount of money" and to "keep at it until the safe is empty."
She rarely grants interviews and did not respond to a request for comment from NPR for this story. In keeping with her low-profile approach to gift-giving in the last several years, she has only vaguely explained her rationale for deciding whom to fund and, until December 2022, did not even have a website that tracked the gifts.
Initially, some potential recipients ignored Scott's representatives' emails or hung up on their calls, believing them to be scams or hoaxes. For many of Scott's recipients, it was the largest grant they have ever received.
The lack of information about Scott's team, method and decision-making process has invited some skepticism. Stanford University professor and co-director of the Center on Philanthropy and Civil Society Rob Reich told Bloomberg in 2021:
"She owes her fellow citizens greater transparency over the power she's wielding. Scrutiny does not mean condemnation; it just means we deserve to ask questions."
Scott appears to have taken this advice and in December, unveiled the website with a database listing her donations, with plans to detail the selection criteria and to launch a process for nonprofits to apply for grants.
Some experts like Sir Stephen Bubb, head of the Gradel Institute of Charity at the University of Oxford, say that the need for greater openness does not always apply.
"If it's public sector money then absolutely there has to be transparency and proper processes. If it's philanthropy I think a freer more interesting approach is appropriate," Bubb says.
Peter Grant, from Bayes Business School in London, agrees, saying it's important to not discourage people from making gifts. "The quicker and easier you make it to get that money out of your bank account and into things that are making the world better, then the more effective grant making will be," he says.
It doesn't appear that Scott has been deterred by critics, and in November 2022, she outlined that her giving was targeted toward "supporting the voices and opportunities of people from underserved communities." In 2020, she announced that she had already contributed more than $586 million to causes supporting racial equality. Most of the initial grants have been to U.S.-focused initiatives, but some are international in scope like a $15 million gift to VisionSpring, a social enterprise that provides low-cost eyeglasses to workers in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia.
VisionSpring's CEO Ella Gudwin describes Scott's support as a "big win" for the sector. "This is believed to be the largest, single private donation toward solving the problem of uncorrected blurry vision as a poverty intervention," she says.
Most notable in Scott's gifts is the lack of any reporting requirements, something that nonprofit workers like Water For People's Williford heartily welcome.
"People don't realize how much time organizations spend on allocating restricted resources. A lot of people say, 'I want to make sure my money goes only to programming, not to overhead.' " But, she says that overhead is important — it's "salaries, fundraising and keeping lights on."
She also says that it is common for donors to have specific geographic preferences for their gift.
"If you get different restrictions, you are constantly having to reallocate resources and reserves."
Bubb says that an unrestricted approach is a blow against bureaucracy.
"Philanthropic foundations have been far too process-driven, deciding what's best for charities and making them jump through hoops with over-elaborate application arrangements."
A report by the Center for Effective Philanthropy (CEP), based on interviews with Scott's beneficiaries, found that the effects of the largesse have been "dramatically and profoundly positive." It outlines how organizations' initial concerns of not having the capacity to absorb such a large donation or deterring other donors, have largely been allayed. On the contrary, the report notes that leaders surveyed, "report a new sense of empowerment and agency."
(The CEP has previously received a grant from Scott but notes that the report did not receive any funding from her.)
Meanwhile, Williford and her colleagues at Water For People are able to concentrate on their goal of providing sustainable clean water access to everyone by 2030 and assist their expansion into Tanzania.
"Unrestricted donations in a vacuum is not the solution but the more that donors do trust-based philanthropy — building a relationship and doing due diligence — the more time can be spent on project delivery."
Andrew Connelly is a British freelance journalist focusing on politics, migration and conflict. He tweets @connellyandrew.
veryGood! (345)
Related
- Walmart boosts its outlook for 2024 with bargains proving a powerful lure for the inflation weary
- Global carbon emissions set record high, but US coal use drops to levels last seen in 1903
- Detroit on track to record fewest homicides since 1966, officials say
- ‘That's authoritarianism’: Florida argues school libraries are for government messaging
- Wally Amos, 88, of cookie fame, died at home in Hawaii. He lost Famous Amos but found other success
- Father of slain Italian woman challenges men to be agents of change against femicide
- The holidays are here. So is record credit card debt. How 6 Americans are coping.
- Judge weighing Ohio abortion rights amendment’s legal impact keeps anti-abortion groups clear
- 51 Must-Try Stress Relief & Self-Care Products for National Relaxation Day (& National Wellness Month)
- Allison Williams' new podcast revisits the first murder trial in U.S. history: A test drive for the Constitution
Ranking
- Don't be fooled by the name and packaging: Fruit snacks are rarely good for you. Here's why.
- Woman killed in shark attack while swimming with young daughter off Mexico's Pacific coast
- Wikipedia, wrapped. Here are 2023’s most-viewed articles on the internet’s encyclopedia
- Trial to determine whether JetBlue can buy Spirit, further consolidating industry, comes to a head
- The State Fair of Texas is banning firearms, drawing threats of legal action from Republican AG
- Cause sought of explosion that leveled an Arlington, Virginia, home as police tried to serve warrant
- Former Miss America Runner-Up Cullen Johnson Hill Shares Her Addiction Struggles After Jail Time
- George Santos is offering personalized videos for $200
Recommendation
-
Usher Cancels Atlanta Concert Hours Before Show to Rest and Heal
-
Dane County looks to stop forcing unwed fathers to repay Medicaid birth costs from before 2020
-
Jodie Sweetin Reveals the Parenting Advice the Full House Men Gave That's Anything But Rude
-
11 hikers dead, 12 missing after Indonesia's Marapi volcano erupts
-
Red Cross blood inventory plummets 25% in July, impacted by heat and record low donations
-
Don't blame CFP committee for trying to be perfect with an imperfect system
-
Ukrainian officials say Russian shelling has hit a southern city, killing 2 people in the street
-
After racist shooting that killed 3, family sues Dollar General and others over lax security