Current:Home > ScamsDemocrat Evers, Republican Vos both argue against Supreme Court taking voucher lawsuit-DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews & Ratings
Democrat Evers, Republican Vos both argue against Supreme Court taking voucher lawsuit
lotradecoin automated trading strategies View Date:2024-12-25 22:23:31
MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Democratic Gov. Tony Evers’ administration and political opponent Republican Assembly Speaker Robin Vos are in the rare position of taking the same side in a lawsuit seeking to end Wisconsin’s taxpayer-funded voucher school system, telling the Wisconsin Supreme Court that it should not take the case.
Vos and Department of Administration Secretary Kathy Blumenfeld, who was appointed by Evers, told the court in separate filings this week that the case should start at the circuit court level. The third defendant, Department of Public Instruction Secretary Jill Underly, took no position. Underly, who was elected on a nonpartisan ballot, was backed by Democrats.
Democratic opponents of the voucher program took a different position from Evers and asked the state Supreme Court to take the case directly. If it does, it would issue a ruling within weeks or months. It would likely take two or three years for the case to work through the lower courts.
Brian Potts, attorney for those challenging the voucher programs, said “it’s incredibly disappointing” that Evers has aligned himself with Vos.
“We hope the Supreme Court sees through the difficult politics associated with this issue and decides to stand up to the Republican Legislature and protect Wisconsin’s public school children,” Potts said Thursday.
Evers’ spokesperson Britt Cudaback did not return a message seeking comment.
Evers, who previously served as state superintendent of education, has been a longtime critic of the voucher program. But this summer, he agreed to increase spending on the program as part of a larger education funding package tied to a deal sending more money to Milwaukee and local governments.
The arguments from Vos and the Evers administration line up with other supporters of the voucher school programs, including Wisconsin Manufacturers and Commerce and the conservative Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty which is representing private schools, parents of students who attend them and other advocates of the program.
They argue that the case should start in circuit court, so the lower courts can determine an array of facts before the Wisconsin Supreme Court has to weigh in.
Underly, in a one-page filing, said she was taking no position because her “primary concern is oversight and supervision of public instruction.” But, she said, if the court takes the case, Underly “may take a position on the accuracy of any factual assertions made by any party.”
When the lawsuit was filed last month, Underly seemed in alignment with those challenging the voucher school system by saying that she welcomed any opportunity to “effectively, equitably, and robustly fund our public education system.”
Democrats have argued for decades that the voucher school program is a drain on resources that would otherwise go to public schools.
The lawsuit argues that the state’s revenue limit and funding mechanism for voucher school programs and charter schools violate the Wisconsin Constitution’s declaration that public funds be spent for public purposes. It also contends that vouchers defund public schools, do not allow for adequate public oversight and do not hold private schools to the same standards as public schools.
The nation’s first school choice program began in Milwaukee in 1990. Then seen as an experiment to help low-income students in the state’s largest city, the program has expanded statewide and its income restrictions have been loosened. This year, nearly 55,000 students were enrolled.
Evers appointee Blumenfeld argued that ending the voucher program immediately, as the lawsuit requests, “could lead to chaotic and unanticipated outcomes.” Trying to absorb those students in the public school system “could lead to staffing, funding, and classroom shortages,” Blumenfeld said.
The lawsuit was filed two months after the state Supreme Court flipped to 4-3 liberal controlled.
The lawsuit was brought by several Wisconsin residents and is being funded by the liberal Minocqua Brewing Super PAC. Kirk Bangstad, who owns the Minocqua Brewing Co., is a former Democratic candidate for U.S. House and state Assembly.
veryGood! (49)
Related
- Gena Rowlands, acting powerhouse and star of movies by her director-husband, John Cassavetes, dies
- Authorities to announce new break in long investigation of Gilgo Beach killings
- Browns rally past Jets in Hall of Fame Game after lights briefly go out
- Mega Millions players will have another chance on Friday night to win a $1.25 billion jackpot
- Ranking MLB jersey advertisements: Whose patch is least offensive?
- Extreme heat has caused several hiking deaths this summer. Here's how to stay safe.
- Prosecutor wants to defend conviction of former Missouri detective who killed Black man
- Having trouble hearing 'Oppenheimer' dialogue? Director Christopher Nolan explains why
- Emily in Paris' Ashley Park Reveals How Lily Collins Predicted Her Relationship With Costar Paul Forman
- Why are actors making movies during the strike? What to know about SAG-AFTRA waivers
Ranking
- Big Georgia county to start charging some costs to people who challenge the eligibility of voters
- New Jersey house explosion leaves 2 dead, 2 missing, 2 children injured
- Rising temperatures could impact quality of grapes used to make wine in Napa Valley
- Olivia Munn Reflects on Her 20-Month Postpartum Journey After Wearing Pre-Baby Shorts
- Las Vegas police could boycott working NFL games over new facial ID policy
- FBI gives lie-detector tests to family of missing Wisconsin boy James Yoblonski
- US economy likely generated 200,000 new jobs in July, showing more resilience in face of rate hikes
- Kelsea Ballerini Urges Fans Not to Dig Up Morgan Evans Divorce Drama Ahead of Extended EP Release
Recommendation
-
The Sunscreen and Moisturizer Duo That Saved My Skin on a Massively Hot European Vacation
-
Houston volunteer found not guilty for feeding the homeless. Now he's suing the city.
-
Freight train derails in upstate New York, disrupting Amtrak service
-
Fall in Love with These 14 Heart-Stopping Gifts in This Ultimate Heartstopper Fan Guide
-
As Baltimore’s Sewer System Buckles Under Extreme Weather, City Refuses to Help Residents With Cleanup Efforts
-
Houston volunteer found not guilty for feeding the homeless. Now he's suing the city.
-
New Jersey to hold three-day state funeral for late Lt. Gov. Sheila Oliver
-
A Learjet pilot thought he was cleared to take off. He wasn’t. Luckily, JetBlue pilots saw him