Current:Home > NewsAdding up the Public Health Costs of Using Coal to Make Steel-DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews & Ratings
Adding up the Public Health Costs of Using Coal to Make Steel
lotradecoin liquidity View Date:2024-12-25 14:37:20
Last year, researchers at New York University published a startling conclusion: The 2016 closure of the Shenango Coke Works, a coal-powered manufacturing facility outside Pittsburgh, was linked to “near-instant decreases in local heart-related emergency department visits and hospitalizations for cardiovascular diseases” in the surrounding area. Coke is a derivative of coal that is used in steelmaking, and the study provided persuasive evidence of the dangers for nearby residents.
A new report aims to quantify the costs and damage to public health that steelmaking that still relies on coal causes—not just in one Pennsylvania neighborhood, but across the country.
The report found that cancer rates related to air pollution are 12 percent higher near these steel plants than national rates and 26 percent higher for residents living near coke plants. Researchers used modeling to link increased cases of asthma symptoms to the toxic byproducts, like sulfur dioxide and lead, emitted from coal-based steelmaking plants.
Explore the latest news about what’s at stake for the climate during this election season.
Based on data from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s National Emissions Inventory, the report concluded that this sector of the steel industry caused between $6.9 billion and $13.2 billion in health impacts such as premature deaths and emergency room visits, along with an estimated $137 million in economic losses every year from missed work days and other ripple effects. In the United States and abroad, coal-based steelmaking is also a significant contributor to climate change, pumping out 11 percent of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions.
Although coal was once the dominant source of fuel for America’s steel industry, today there are only seven coal-based steel plants and 10 coke plants in the United States. The facilities are dotted across the Midwest and Appalachia; the country’s largest coke plant, the 123-year-old Clairton Coke Works, is in Pennsylvania. The majority of steel made in America today is manufactured in electric arc furnaces from recycled scrap steel, a less-polluting process than the older methods to make new steel.
Kevin Dempsey, president and CEO of the American Steel and Iron Institute, a trade group for the steel industry, said in a statement that American steel companies are “dedicated environmental stewards with a strong commitment to the communities in which they operate.”
“Our industry is recognized as among the lowest carbon- and other emissions-intensive steel industries in the world,” he said.
Hilary Lewis, the steel director at Industrious Labs, a nonprofit that focuses on decarbonizing heavy industry and that produced the report, said she was surprised by the big impact of such a small number of facilities. “There aren’t actually that many left,” she said.
That shrinking footprint is part of the challenge of raising awareness about the outsized effects of just 17 plants. Even in former steel towns, where the old mills have closed, people don’t know that steel is still being made in the United States with coal. “There has not been a huge innovation in how we make steel, and it’s still a coal-based process with big smokestacks and coke and high temperatures,” Lewis said. “The working conditions are much less dangerous than they used to be, but the basic technology has stayed the same.”
Lewis said Industrious Labs wanted to make this data available to community members who live near the plants but may not have access to specifics and metrics about the pollution in their neighborhoods. “Having access to this data was really important to them and not something they had in the past,” she said. “They lived in Gary, Indiana, or East Chicago, right next to these facilities their whole lives, and they didn’t know that there was lead coming out of these smokestacks.”
“A lot of times people are led to believe that it’s genetics, and that’s a narrative that must change.”
— Germaine Patterson, a community health worker
For Germaine Patterson, a community health worker in Clairton, Pennsylvania, who was interviewed for the report and who has seen firsthand the health impacts that come from living next to a coke plant, the data was more evidence of a problem she and others in Clairton are well aware of. “It’s not anything that I haven’t heard before, that’s for sure,” she said.
Even so, the projected statistics for asthma (250,504 cases of symptoms per year) and premature deaths (between 460 and 892 annually) connected to air pollution from coal-based steelmaking surprised her.
“A lot of times people are led to believe that it’s genetics, and that’s a narrative that must change,” she said. Patterson hoped the report would reach policymakers and motivate them to push for better health protections for frontline communities.
Industrious Labs wants to make the case for transitioning these remaining mills to green steelmaking, which uses direct reduced iron and renewable energy sources like green hydrogen. Green steelmaking can cut emissions by 95 percent compared to coal-based steelmaking. Direct reduced iron can be made without coal because it is produced in furnaces that operate below the melting point of iron.
Lewis said climate advocates don’t want old steel plants to close, becoming relics of an earlier industrial age as they have in other parts of the country. Instead, they believe transitioning to green steelmaking could revitalize steel communities economically and drastically alter public health outcomes for their residents.
“What we need is [for] companies to invest. We need the government to support this transition,” she said. More legislation like the Inflation Reduction Act is necessary to help the industry move away from coal, she said.
In his statement, Dempsey touted “tens of millions of dollars” of investments that American companies have already made in direct reduced iron and ongoing partnerships with the government to make green steelmaking a reality. “Several American steel producers are actively partnering with the Department of Energy on new initiatives to facilitate further investments in lower emissions steelmaking in the United States,” he said.
Although green steelmaking is not yet widespread, Lewis sees proof of its bright future in new facilities being built with the technology in Ohio, Ontario and Sweden. “This transition is underway,” she said.
About This Story
Perhaps you noticed: This story, like all the news we publish, is free to read. That’s because Inside Climate News is a 501c3 nonprofit organization. We do not charge a subscription fee, lock our news behind a paywall, or clutter our website with ads. We make our news on climate and the environment freely available to you and anyone who wants it.
That’s not all. We also share our news for free with scores of other media organizations around the country. Many of them can’t afford to do environmental journalism of their own. We’ve built bureaus from coast to coast to report local stories, collaborate with local newsrooms and co-publish articles so that this vital work is shared as widely as possible.
Two of us launched ICN in 2007. Six years later we earned a Pulitzer Prize for National Reporting, and now we run the oldest and largest dedicated climate newsroom in the nation. We tell the story in all its complexity. We hold polluters accountable. We expose environmental injustice. We debunk misinformation. We scrutinize solutions and inspire action.
Donations from readers like you fund every aspect of what we do. If you don’t already, will you support our ongoing work, our reporting on the biggest crisis facing our planet, and help us reach even more readers in more places?
Please take a moment to make a tax-deductible donation. Every one of them makes a difference.
Thank you,
David Sassoon
Founder and Publisher
Vernon Loeb
Executive Editor
Share this article
- Republish
veryGood! (37)
Related
- Wildfires are growing under climate change, and their smoke threatens farmworkers, study says
- BeatKing, Houston Rapper Also Known as Club Godzilla, Dead at 39
- Watchdogs want US to address extreme plutonium contamination in Los Alamos’ Acid Canyon
- Evers’ transportation secretary will resign in September to take job at UW-Madison
- Hideki Matsuyama will be without regular caddie, coach after their passports and visas were stolen
- Man didn’t know woman he fatally shot in restaurant drive-thru before killing himself, police say
- Recalled cucumbers in salmonella outbreak sickened 449 people in 31 states, CDC reports
- Newlyweds and bride’s mother killed in crash after semitruck overturns in Colorado
- 'Truffles is just like me:' How a Pennsylvania cat makes kids feel proud to wear glasses
- Could Alex Murdaugh get new trial for South Carolina murders of wife and son?
Ranking
- Infamous LA officer’s gun found in $1 million watch robbery case
- Jewish groups file federal complaint alleging antisemitism in Fulton schools
- Federal subpoenas issued in probe of New York Mayor Eric Adams’ 2021 campaign
- Amid Matthew Perry arrests, should doctors be blamed for overdose deaths?
- Usher concert postponed hours before tour opener in Atlanta
- Watch mom freeze in shock when airman son surprises her after two years apart
- Matthew Perry’s death leads to sweeping indictment of 5, including doctors and reputed dealers
- Katy Perry to receive Video Vanguard Award and perform live at 2024 MTV VMAs
Recommendation
-
Wisconsin’s Evers urges federal judge not to make changes at youth prison in wake of counselor death
-
Cardinals superfan known as Rally Runner gets 10 months in prison for joining Jan. 6 Capitol riot
-
US consumer sentiment rises slightly on Democratic optimism over Harris’ presidential prospects
-
Sofia Richie Shares Special Way She’s Cherishing Mom Life With Baby Eloise
-
Lady Gaga’s Brunette Hair Transformation Will Have You Applauding
-
Kim Dotcom loses 12-year fight to halt deportation from New Zealand to face US copyright case
-
Jordanian citizen charged for attacking Florida energy plant, threats condemning Israel
-
The Daily Money: Inflation eased in July