Current:Home > ContactIn Utah and Kansas, state courts flex power over new laws regulating abortion post-Roe-DB Wealth Institute B2 Reviews & Ratings
In Utah and Kansas, state courts flex power over new laws regulating abortion post-Roe
lotradecoin referral program benefits View Date:2025-01-12 14:37:23
OLATHE, Kan. (AP) — State courts have become hot spots in the national abortion debate, with Utah’s top court and a Kansas judge considering Tuesday whether their state constitutions require them to block or invalidate laws regulating the procedure more than a year after Roe v. Wade was overturned.
The U.S. Supreme Court’s June 2022 decision in Dobbs v. Jackson transformed what was long a debate over the U.S. Constitution, immediately limiting the pathways abortion advocates could take in challenging restrictions from one state to the next.
“State courts are incredibly important in this moment when patients are having difficulty accessing abortion because many states have banned it entirely so patients are traveling hundreds or even thousands of miles,” Alice Wang, a Center for Reproductive Rights attorney, told reporters after arguing providers’ case in a courtroom in the Kansas City area.
In Kansas, the legal battle is over how providers dispense abortion medications, what they must tell patients and a required 24-hour wait for an abortion after information required by the state is provided to the patient.
Questions about those restrictions hinge on the state constitution — and on the Kansas Supreme Court’s 2019 decision declaring bodily autonomy a “fundamental” right that protects abortion access. Kansas doesn’t ban most abortions until the 22nd week of pregnancy.
Judge K. Christopher Jayaram was skeptical of parts of those requirements, including provisions in place for years, but did not rule from the bench. He repeatedly questioned an attorney for the anti-abortion Alliance Defending Freedom who was arguing for the state.
The new Kansas law, which took effect July 1, requires providers to tell patients a medication abortion can be stopped once it is started with a regimen that major medical groups call unproven and potentially dangerous. While the state is free to regulate an area of medical “uncertainty,” Jayaram told the alliance’s attorney, Denise Harle, that the medical literature he’s read suggests there’s no good, valid study supporting the regimen.
“I’m concerned about that,” he said.
The state and the providers mutually agreed that the new law wouldn’t be enforced at least until Jayaram decides whether to block the law and the other requirements while a trial of the providers’ lawsuit against it goes forward.
Harle said those requirements don’t limit bodily autonomy but bolster it by giving patients more information.
“It’s not a right to unregulated abortion,” she said in court.
In Utah, the state’s attorneys want the state Supreme Court to overrule a lower court’s decision to put a 2020 state law banning most abortions on hold. They argued the “original public meaning” of the state constitution drafted in the Mormon Pioneer era in 1895 didn’t guarantee a right to abortion.
“There is no constitutional text, history or common law tradition that can support it, and yet the state’s law has been under way for one year and 28 days, allowing thousands of abortions to proceed,” said Taylor Meehan, Utah’s outside counsel, echoing an argument Kansas made before the 2019 decision of its highest court.
Planned Parenthood Association of Utah’s attorney Camila Vega argued that the right to an abortion aligned with the court’s prior rulings on the Utah Constitution, fell under a broadly defined right to bodily autonomy and ensured other protected rights could be equally guaranteed to men and women.
In Kansas, providers argued that bans in other states only heighten the harm caused by the state’s restrictions because patients are traveling much farther for care. Outside the courthouse in Salt Lake City, Planned Parenthood of Utah CEO Kathryn Boyd said if the trigger law takes effect, “Thousands will be forced to flee their communities for basic health care or carry pregnancies to term against their will.”
The Kansas and Utah cases reflect how the impact of the overturning of Roe remains unsettled 13 months later. Republican-controlled legislatures, including in Utah and Kansas, have since pushed to tighten laws surrounding abortion, prompting fierce court battles from the doctors and clinics providing them.
Kansas voters scrambled the national debate last year by decisively rejecting a proposed change in the state constitution sought by GOP lawmakers to say it doesn’t grant a right to abortion. Anti-abortion groups warned that without the change — and its rebuke of the Kansas Supreme Court — the state’s existing restrictions could fall.
Kentucky also voted to protect abortion rights last year, and Ohio voters on Tuesday went to the polls to vote on requirements to amend the state’s constitution.
Utah is one of at least five states in which laws restricting abortion have been put on hold amid litigation. In Utah, the result is that abortion isn’t banned until the 18th week of pregnancy, but lawmakers subsequently passed additional legislation striking licensing provisions for abortion clinics from state code in an effort to phase them out.
In arguments Tuesday, Utah’s majority-women Supreme Court appeared skeptical of the state’s claims that the lower court abused its power in putting an abortion law on hold last year. The panel probed Utah’s attorneys about arguments that the state’s Planned Parenthood affiliate had not raised “serious issues” enough to merit delaying the law.
In the days or weeks ahead, the Utah justices are expected to decide whether to maintain the lower court’s hold on the abortion law or take the matter into their own hands due to the state constitutional questions at stake.
___
Metz reported from Salt Lake City, Utah. Associated Press writer Geoff Mulvihill contributed from Cherry Hill, New Jersey. Follow Metz at https://twitter.com/metzsam and Hanna at https://twitter.com/apjdhanna .
veryGood! (61227)
Related
- Alabama Supreme Court authorizes third nitrogen gas execution
- Jimmy Kimmel mocks Donald Trump for Oscars rant, reveals he may now host ceremony again
- Alabama plans to eliminate tolls en route to the beach
- Coalition to submit 900,000 signatures to put tough-on-crime initiative on California ballot
- NASA still hasn't decided the best way to get the Starliner crew home: 'We've got time'
- Netflix now has nearly 270 million subscribers after another strong showing to begin 2024
- Not only New York casinos threaten Atlantic City. Developer predicts Meadowlands casino is coming
- Pepsi Lime or Pepsi Peach? 2 limited-edition sodas to make debut in time for summer
- Austin Dillon loses automatic playoff berth for actions in crash-filled NASCAR win
- Supreme Court to weigh whether bans targeting homeless encampments run afoul of the Constitution
Ranking
- Detroit judge orders sleepy teenage girl on field trip to be handcuffed, threatens jail
- Arkansas Supreme Court says new DNA testing can be sought in ‘West Memphis 3' case
- 2 more endangered ferrets cloned from animal frozen in the 1980s: Science takes time
- These Cookbooks Will Save You From Boring Meals This Summer
- Get 70% Off Kate Spade, 70% Off Coach, 40% Off Banana Republic, 40% Off Disney & Today's Top Deals
- Saving 'Stumpy': How residents in Washington scramble to save this one cherry tree
- Most student loan borrowers have delayed major life events due to debt, recent poll says
- Officer fatally shoots man who confronted him with knife, authorities say
Recommendation
-
'Love Island UK' stars Molly-Mae Hague, Tommy Fury announce split after 5 years
-
Saving 'Stumpy': How residents in Washington scramble to save this one cherry tree
-
Workers at Mercedes factories near Tuscaloosa, Alabama, to vote in May on United Auto Workers union
-
The Latest | Officials at Group of Seven meeting call for new sanctions against Iran
-
The Notebook Actress Gena Rowlands Dead at 94
-
Civilian interrogator defends work at Abu Ghraib, tells jury he was promoted
-
Here's how much Caitlin Clark will make in the WNBA
-
Bryan Kohberger's attorneys claim cellphone data shows he was not at home where murders took place